Katie Grinnell, a registered nurse who worked at Central Maine Medical Center in Lewiston and a member of the National Nurses Organizing Committee, and April Potvin, a vascular access nurse at the hospital who helped organize nurses, joined the America's Work Force Union Podcast to discuss the nurses' vote to join the Maine State Nurses Association, an affiliate of National Nurses United.
Grinnell and Potvin described what led nurses to organize, the vote count, the price some paid and what they expect as first-contract bargaining begins.
Katie Grinnell, a registered nurse who worked at Central Maine Medical Center in Lewiston and a member of the National Nurses Organizing Committee, and April Potvin, a vascular access nurse at the hospital who helped organize nurses, joined America's Work Force Union Podcast to discuss the nurses' 91 percent vote to join the Maine State Nurses Association, an affiliate of National Nurses United.
Grinnell said conditions at the hospital, located in a largely rural state, were not great before it was acquired by Prime Healthcare. She said Prime promised to invest in the hospital and community and to create jobs, but it became evident soon after the acquisition that Prime was not interested in making any investments. Almost immediately, she saw things decline.
Grinnell explained that 91 percent of the hospital’s nurses voted to organize, and called the result astounding. She said management initially refused to let nurses into the building for the public vote count, but the nurses countered that it was a public event, and 13 were allowed in. As they tallied the votes, she said that she realized the moment they passed a majority that they had won.
Tears ran down her face, Grinnell admitted, because for the first time in the hospital's history nurses had a seat at the table and a voice to change the working conditions that affect their jobs and patient outcomes. She said the tears carried not only joy, but also frustration that it had to come to this. However, the result was a source of comfort, as nurses and the community could finally get what they deserve, including supported lunch breaks. She called it a huge milestone and added that it was just the beginning.
Grinnell was terminated from her position. She said the push to organize was never about her but about the nurses and the community. Late in the campaign, she recalled that she turned down potential promotions because this was bigger. Knowing the outcome, Grinnell said she would do it all over again, because in her eyes, the end justifies the means.
She would love to return to her former position, Grinnell said. If the National Labor Relations Board finds she was illegally terminated, she does not believe Prime will have a choice to bring her back, though she would prefer the hospital itself to decide that it wants her back, not because of an NLRB ruling.
Hospitals that do not want unions rely on instilling fear, Grinnell said. However, in this case, the nurses got angry, she said, and added that good nurses are needed at the bedside. One person standing up has a compounding effect, she stated, and there is power in numbers: stand up, speak up and fight.
Potvin said she told her fellow nurses that fear is an emotion, while the movement is the action. She explained to them that actions and feelings do not have to match: nurses can be afraid and still stand together because of the better space it will create. She tells frightened kids getting IVs the same, she added.
Grinnell explained the reason for delay on a first contract: if a union does not secure an agreement within a year, the employer can try to reverse it, and she said management is strategic about delaying. They know what they are doing.
Potvin said the hospital is promoting Walk-In Wednesdays, hiring providers on the spot, including a $20,000 sign-on bonus because it urgently needs staff. In her experience, she said, a higher sign-on bonus typically signals worse retention, and new graduates may walk into a storm without knowing it. Reinstating the 20 nurses who were suspended or fired would ease the shortage, she added.
Potvin alleges that new hires sign what appears to be routine HR paperwork, but in fact it is arbitration paperwork with fine print about union organizing and penalties. Younger nurses can then be told they will lose their jobs if they organize, she explained. Although she believes such actions are illegal, Maine is an at-will state, which makes the battle difficult.
Potvin said a large education campaign involving the community and nurses will target new graduates, prospective students and nurses precepting with them. Maine is a large state but a small community, she said, so word will get out. She said she is open to hearing from nurses elsewhere and is watching the struggle at Brigham and Women's because every nurse needs the support of every other nurse.
Grinnell's message to nurses working in what she called subprime conditions is to stand up, talk with colleagues, hold discussions and reach out to the Maine State Nurses Association, an affiliate of National Nurses United, the largest and fastest-growing nurses union with more than 225,000 members, she said. Someone will fight alongside them, she said, so corporate greed cannot take these things from nurses at the bedside.
More information on National Nurses United is available at nationalnursesunited.org, and on the National Nurses Organizing Committee at nationalnursesunited.org/nnoc.
Every victory at the bargaining table starts with workers standing together. From the shop floor to the statehouse, hear how activists are fighting for better wages, safer conditions and a stronger future. Subscribe to the America's Work Force Union Podcast to get the latest interviews with the leaders and organizers building worker power across America.